Skip to content 
Foot discomfort can quickly turn into a daily struggle — especially when it involves your toes. One common issue that often sneaks up gradually is hammertoe, a condition where one or more toes become bent in a curled or claw-like position. Over time, it can lead to pain, calluses, and difficulty finding comfortable footwear.
If you’re dealing with this condition in Pensacola, FL, the good news is that hammertoe is treatable, and early care can prevent long-term complications. Whether you’re noticing mild discomfort or a more pronounced deformity, understanding the causes and your treatment options is the first step toward relief.
This guide explains what hammertoe is, what causes it, and the most effective nonsurgical and surgical treatment options available today.
What Is Hammertoe?
Hammertoe is a deformity of the toe joints, most often affecting the second, third, or fourth toes. The condition causes the toe to bend downward at the middle joint (called the proximal interphalangeal joint), giving it a hammer-like appearance.
Hammertoes may be:
- Flexible — Early-stage and still able to be straightened with effort
- Rigid — More advanced, with limited mobility and permanent stiffness
Left untreated, hammertoe can worsen over time — leading to corns, painful rubbing inside shoes, and difficulty walking comfortably.
What Causes Hammertoe?
Hammertoe is usually the result of muscle and tendon imbalance, which places abnormal pressure on the joints. Over time, the tendons tighten, and the toe becomes stuck in a bent position.
Common contributing factors include:
- Ill-fitting shoes — Tight, narrow, or high-heeled shoes can force the toes into unnatural positions
- Foot structure — People with flat feet, high arches, or bunions are more prone to muscle imbalances
- Toe injuries — Trauma or repetitive strain can lead to instability in the toe joints
- Arthritis — Joint inflammation may weaken or destabilize the small toe joints
- Genetics — A family history of foot deformities increases risk
In many cases, multiple factors work together over time to cause the condition — especially when combined with poor footwear choices.
Symptoms of Hammertoe
The symptoms of hammertoe usually develop slowly and may begin with mild irritation or visible toe curvature. Without treatment, symptoms can become more severe and affect your daily comfort.
Common signs include:
- A toe that bends downward at the middle joint
- Pain or irritation while walking or wearing shoes
- Corns or calluses on the top of the bent toe or between toes
- Redness or swelling around the affected joint
- Reduced flexibility or stiffness in the toe
- Difficulty fitting into shoes
If you notice any of these signs, it’s a good idea to seek early evaluation — especially if you’ve had foot problems in the past or regularly wear tight shoes.
Non-Surgical Treatment Options for Hammertoe
Many cases of hammertoe, especially in the flexible stage, can be managed without surgery. Conservative care focuses on reducing pain, improving toe alignment, and preventing further progression.
1. Wider, Supportive Footwear
Wearing shoes with a wide toe box, low heel, and good arch support can ease pressure on the bent toe. Avoid pointy or high-heeled styles.
2. Orthotic Inserts
Custom or over-the-counter orthotics can help redistribute pressure and correct imbalances that contribute to hammertoe formation.
3. Toe Splints or Straighteners
Devices like toe splints, cushions, or gel pads help hold the toe in a more natural position and reduce friction in shoes.
4. Foot Exercises and Stretching
Gentle stretches can improve flexibility and muscle balance, particularly if the toe is still flexible. Examples include:
- Towel scrunches with your toes
- Picking up marbles
- Stretching the toe manually several times a day
5. Corn and Callus Care
Padding or trimming corns and calluses (by a professional) can relieve pain caused by rubbing. Do not attempt to cut them at home, especially if you have diabetes.
If these methods provide limited relief or the condition worsens, more advanced options may be considered.
When Is Surgery Recommended?
When hammertoe becomes rigid or causes significant pain despite conservative treatment, surgical correction may be the best option. Surgery is often outpatient and may involve:
Common procedures:
- Tendon release or transfer — To balance the toe’s pull and improve alignment
- Joint resection — Removing part of the bone to straighten the toe
- Fusion (arthrodesis) — Joining bones together to stabilize the joint
Surgery is typically recommended when the deformity is severe, the toe is fixed in a bent position, or non-invasive treatments have failed to provide lasting relief.
What Does Recovery Look Like?
Recovery from hammertoe treatment depends on whether surgery was required and the severity of the condition.
- Non-surgical care may show improvement in a few weeks with proper footwear and stretching
- Post-surgery recovery usually takes 6–8 weeks for full healing
- Patients often wear a post-op shoe or boot to protect the toe during healing
- Swelling, stiffness, and minor discomfort are common early on but improve with time
Physical therapy or home exercises may be recommended to regain motion and prevent stiffness.
Preventing Hammertoe Progression
Taking care of your feet today can prevent worsening symptoms in the future. Simple habits go a long way in keeping toes healthy.
Prevention tips:
- Choose shoes that fit properly and offer enough toe space
- Avoid high heels or narrow-toed shoes when possible
- Stretch and strengthen your toes regularly
- Address bunions or flat feet early to reduce imbalance
- Monitor foot health, especially if you have diabetes or arthritis
The earlier hammertoe is addressed, the more likely it is to respond well to conservative care.
Get Hammertoe Relief in Pensacola, FL
Hammertoe can be uncomfortable, unsightly, and eventually limiting — but it’s absolutely treatable. With the right care, you can relieve pain, restore toe function, and enjoy more comfortable movement.
If you're seeking expert hammertoe treatment in Pensacola, FL, Emerald Coast Foot and Ankle Center is here to help. From conservative care to advanced surgical solutions, we offer personalized treatment plans that get you back on your feet with confidence. Schedule your consultation today.